Every listing links straight to the retailer's own store

Buying guide · 6 min read

Your first fantasy toy: how to choose size, firmness and shape

Sculpted dragons, sea serpents, rich colours: fantasy toys are a world of their own. Here is how to choose a first one you will actually enjoy.

Published · By Velvet Hoard

A green scaled dragon egg on a dark pedestal, with smaller fantasy pieces around it

Fantasy toys are sculpted after dragons, sea creatures and other beings of myth. Many are poured by hand in small batches, in colours and textures you will not find anywhere else. That is the fun of it, and also why choosing your first one can feel confusing: sizes are listed in different ways, firmness comes in several options, and every maker uses its own names. This guide keeps it simple.

  • Size: look at width, not only length, and start smaller than you think.
  • Firmness: soft or medium is the easiest place to begin.
  • Shape: a tapered tip and gentle texture are kindest for a first toy.
  • Safety: anything for anal use needs a wide, flared base. No exceptions.
  • Material: choose 100% platinum-cure silicone from a maker that says so clearly.

What makes a toy "fantasy"?

A fantasy toy is an adult toy designed after a creature that does not exist, or at least not in this form: dragons, griffins, sea serpents, aliens and more. The design is about imagination. Scales, ridges, fins and swirling colours turn something functional into something closer to a sculpture.

The best makers treat them as a craft. They sculpt the original by hand, make moulds from it and pour each toy from liquid silicone, often in small batches. Many let you choose the colour and firmness yourself. This is why fantasy toys usually cost more than mass-produced ones, and why many people keep them for years.

Size: measure, don't guess

Product pages usually list several numbers. The two that matter most are:

  • Usable length: the part that can actually be used, from the tip to where the base or handle begins. Total length includes the base, so it is always bigger.
  • Width (diameter) or girth (circumference): how thick the widest part is. For comfort, this number matters more than length.

Fantasy designs often change width along their length, for example a slim tip that widens into a thicker middle or a knot. Good makers list the width of each part. If you only see one number, it is usually the widest point.

A simple way to compare

Take something you already know is comfortable and measure it with a soft tape measure or a piece of string. Then compare it with the product page. One extra centimetre of width feels much bigger than one extra centimetre of length.

Size names are not the same everywhere

"Small", "medium" and "large" mean different things at different shops, and a medium at one maker can be bigger than a large at another. Always check the measurements, not the size name.

Most people are happier when their first fantasy toy is smaller than they expected to want. You can always size up later. A toy that is too big tends to stay in the drawer.

Firmness: soft, medium, firm and split

Silicone can be made softer or firmer, and many makers let you choose:

  • Soft: squishy and flexible. It gives way easily, which makes larger sizes more comfortable, but fine details feel less defined.
  • Medium: the all-rounder. Flexible enough to be forgiving, firm enough that the shape and texture come through. A good first choice.
  • Firm: holds its shape well and makes textures feel stronger. Usually better once you know which size you like.
  • Split or dual-density: a firmer core inside a softer outer layer, so you get a squishy surface with some backbone underneath. Often a little more expensive.

If you are unsure, choose soft or medium. Firmness is very personal, and plenty of people end up owning the same design in two firmnesses.

Shape and texture

For a first toy, look for:

  • A tapered tip that starts narrow and widens gradually. It is far easier to begin with than a blunt or wide tip.
  • Gentle texture. Scales and soft ridges add sensation. Deep grooves, sharp edges or large knots are better saved for later.
  • A comfortable curve. A slight curve often feels more natural than a perfectly straight shape.

Texture also affects care. The more detail a toy has, the more carefully you need to wash it, because soap and water have to reach every groove.

Many fantasy toys have a suction-cup base or a base that fits a harness. A suction cup only holds on smooth, clean surfaces such as tiles or glass, so do not expect it to stick to wood or painted walls.

Safety first: the flared base rule

Anything meant for anal use must have a wide, flared base. The base stops the toy from slipping all the way inside the body, which can mean a trip to the hospital. Never use a toy without a proper base this way, and never use household objects.

A few more basics:

  • Use plenty of lubricant, and add more whenever you need to.
  • Go slowly, and stop if anything hurts. Pain is a signal, not something to push through.
  • Do not move a toy from anal to vaginal use without washing it thoroughly first, or changing the condom on it. This helps prevent infections.

Material: why platinum silicone

Almost all well-made fantasy toys use platinum-cure silicone. It is non-porous, which means bacteria cannot hide inside the material, and it can be cleaned thoroughly. It is also stable: it does not leak chemicals or turn sticky over time.

Look for a clear statement such as "100% platinum silicone". Be careful with vague words like "silicone blend", "jelly" or "TPE". These materials can be porous and cannot be cleaned as completely. Our guide to body-safe materials explains the differences in detail.

Lube and care basics

  • Use a water-based lubricant with silicone toys. Silicone-based lube can damage the surface of some silicone toys. If you want to use it, test a small hidden spot first, or follow the maker's advice.
  • Wash before the first use and after every use with warm water and mild, unscented soap or a toy cleaner. Pay attention to grooves and textures.
  • Dry it completely before you put it away.
  • Store each toy separately, for example in a cotton bag or its own box, away from dust, heat and direct sunlight.

Some makers say their solid silicone toys can be boiled or washed in a dishwasher to sterilise them. Others do not. Always follow the care guide from the maker of your toy.

Before you buy: what to check

When you find a design you like, check these points on the retailer's page before you order:

  1. Measurements for each part, not just the size name.
  2. Material, stated clearly, ideally "100% platinum silicone".
  3. Firmness options, and how the maker describes each one.
  4. Base type: flared, suction cup or harness-compatible.
  5. Care instructions from the maker.
  6. Packaging and billing: does the parcel look plain, and which name will appear on your bank statement?
  7. Delivery and returns: many makers pour each toy to order, so delivery can take a while. Opened intimate products usually cannot be returned for hygiene reasons.
  8. Import costs: if you live in the EU and order from outside it, VAT and a handling fee may be added. Some shops charge the VAT at checkout; with others, you pay it to the courier on delivery.

Ready to explore?

Browse our Fantasy & Dragons category for dragon-inspired designs, creatures and collectibles, or the fantasy-inspired toys in Adult Toys. Every listing links straight to the retailer's own store, where you can check sizes and firmness options before you decide.

This guide is for general information about products for adults. It is not medical advice. Some links on Velvet Hoard are affiliate links: if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How affiliate links work

Keep reading

Care guide · 4 min read

How to clean and store your toys: a simple routine

A simple routine to clean, dry, charge and store your toys so they stay safe and last for years: by material, for textured fantasy toys and for rechargeables.