Every listing links straight to the retailer's own store

Fantasy know-how · 4 min read

Silicone firmness explained: soft, medium, firm and Shore numbers

Firmness changes how a fantasy toy feels more than almost anything else. Here is what the words and numbers mean, and how to choose.

Published · By Velvet Hoard

Three sculpted fantasy pieces in orange, black and teal on pedestals of rising height

Two fantasy toys can have exactly the same shape and size and still feel completely different. The reason is firmness. Many makers let you choose it, and the choice is often harder than picking the design itself. This guide explains what the options mean in practice.

  • Softer is gentler and more forgiving, especially with larger sizes.
  • Firmer holds its shape and makes textures feel stronger.
  • Split or dual-density combines a soft outside with a firmer core.
  • Size names and firmness names are not standard between makers. Always read each maker's own description.
  • If you are unsure, soft or medium is the safest first choice.

Why firmness matters so much

Firmness affects almost everything about how a toy feels and behaves:

  • Comfort: a softer toy gives way under pressure, so the same size can feel gentler.
  • Texture: on a firmer toy, scales, ridges and other details feel more defined. On a softer toy they are more subtle.
  • Flexibility: softer toys bend more. That can be comfortable, but a very soft toy may feel floppy for some uses.
  • Use with a harness or suction cup: firmer toys usually hold their position better. Very soft ones can bend or wobble.

Soft, medium, firm and split: what they feel like

Soft

Squishy and flexible, with a lot of give. Soft is popular for larger designs, because the toy can compress a little. Details feel gentle rather than sharp. Some people love this; others find it too floppy.

Medium

The middle ground. A medium toy bends when you push it but holds its shape well, and textures come through clearly without feeling intense. If you only buy one toy, medium is rarely a bad choice.

Firm

Firm toys keep their shape and give much less. Textures feel strongest, and the toy feels more solid in the hand. Firm works best once you know which size and shape you enjoy, because it is less forgiving.

Split or dual-density

A split toy is poured in two layers: a firmer core inside a softer outer layer. It feels soft on the surface but has structure underneath, so it combines comfort with control. It often costs a little more, because it takes more work to make.

Shore hardness in plain words

Some makers describe firmness with a Shore hardness number, measured with a tool called a durometer. The basics:

  • Higher numbers mean harder material. Each scale runs from 0 to 100.
  • There are different scales. The Shore 00 scale is used for very soft materials, such as gels and very soft silicones. The Shore A scale is used for firmer rubbers and silicones.
  • You cannot compare numbers from different scales directly. "00-30" and "A 30" are very different hardnesses.

For a feel of the Shore A scale: a rubber band is often given as about A 20, and a pencil eraser at about A 40 to 55, depending on the source. Most soft fantasy toys are softer than an eraser.

Many makers do not publish Shore numbers at all, and simply use "soft", "medium" and "firm". That is fine, but remember that these names are not standard: one maker's medium can feel like another maker's firm. If a maker does publish numbers, compare them only with numbers on the same scale.

How firmness and size work together

Firmness and size are linked. A larger toy in a soft firmness can feel more manageable than a smaller one in firm, because the soft one compresses. So:

  • If you are sizing up, consider going one step softer.
  • If you love strong texture, a firmer toy in a size you already know is a good next step.
  • If you are new to fantasy toys, choose a modest size in soft or medium, and learn what you like before going bigger or firmer.

Our guide to choosing your first fantasy toy explains how to read sizes and measurements.

Firmness and care

Very soft silicone can be more delicate than firm silicone. A few habits help it last:

  • Keep it away from sharp nails, jewellery and rough surfaces.
  • Store it flat or upright in its own pouch, not squashed or folded under other things.
  • Clean it gently, especially around thin details such as fins, tips and edges.

For full cleaning steps, see our guide on how to clean and store your toys.

How to choose: a quick guide

If you…Consider
are buying your first fantasy toySoft or medium, in a modest size
want a larger size to feel comfortableSoft, or split for some structure
want textures to feel as strong as possibleMedium or firm
plan to use a harness or suction cup a lotMedium, firm or split
cannot decide between two firmnessesThe softer one. It is easier to enjoy a toy that is a little too soft than one that is too firm.

Explore fantasy designs

Browse Fantasy & Dragons and the fantasy-inspired toys in Adult Toys. Firmness options are set by each maker, so check the retailer's page for the choices available on each design.

This guide is for general information about products for adults. It is not medical advice. Some links on Velvet Hoard are affiliate links: if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How affiliate links work

Keep reading

Care guide · 4 min read

How to clean and store your toys: a simple routine

A simple routine to clean, dry, charge and store your toys so they stay safe and last for years: by material, for textured fantasy toys and for rechargeables.