
The fantasy toy world ranges from small independent studios, where one person sculpts and pours every piece, to larger brands with big catalogues. Prices, quality and service vary a lot. Instead of asking "which maker is best?", it helps to ask "which maker is best for what I want?". These are the points worth comparing.
- Materials: the maker should clearly say what the toy is made of.
- Sizes and firmness: look for measurements of each part and a choice of firmness.
- Made to order or in stock: this changes delivery time a lot.
- Total cost: include shipping, and import VAT if the maker is outside the EU.
- Service: check the warranty, the returns policy and how easy the maker is to contact.
1. Material: is it clearly stated?
This is the most important point. Good makers say plainly that their toys are made from platinum-cure silicone, and many explain which grade they use and why. Be careful with vague phrases like "silicone blend" or "body-safe material" without any detail. Our guide to body-safe materials explains what to look for.
If a toy has special effects, such as shimmer, glow-in-the-dark or painted details, it is fair to ask the maker how these are made and whether they are safe for the way you plan to use the toy.
2. Handmade or mass-produced?
- Small-batch and handmade: each piece is poured by hand, often to order. Colours can be unique, and small differences between pieces are normal. Delivery usually takes longer, sometimes several weeks.
- Larger production: designs are made in bigger runs, so they are usually in stock and ship faster. Colours and finishes are more consistent, but there are fewer custom options.
Neither is better in itself. It depends on whether you value a one-of-a-kind piece or a quick delivery more.
3. Sizes and measurements
Compare the measurements, not the size names. A good product page lists the usable length and the width of each important part, such as the tip, the middle and any knot or ridge. Some makers offer the same design in several sizes, which makes it easy to start small and size up later. Our guide on choosing your first fantasy toy explains how to read these numbers.
4. Firmness options
Many fantasy makers let you choose soft, medium, firm or a split firmness. Remember that these names are not standard: one maker's medium can feel like another maker's firm. If a maker publishes Shore hardness numbers, compare them only on the same scale. Our guide to silicone firmness explains how.
5. Colours, finishes and custom orders
Colour is a big part of the fun. Some makers offer a fixed palette; others pour custom colourways, swirls and gradients, sometimes as limited releases. Ask yourself whether you want to choose your own colours, and check whether custom orders take longer or cost more.
6. Bases and compatibility
- Flared base: essential for anal use. Check the base width.
- Suction cup: handy for hands-free use, on smooth surfaces only.
- Harness compatibility: check the base shape and size against the harness ring you plan to use.
7. Price: what are you paying for?
Fantasy toys are often more expensive than mainstream toys, and the price usually reflects real costs: more silicone in larger sizes, more complex moulds, hand-poured colours and small-batch work. When you compare prices:
- compare the same size and firmness;
- add shipping and any import costs to get the real total;
- look out for genuine sales and discounted pieces with small cosmetic flaws, which some makers sell at a lower price.
8. Shipping to the EU
If you live in the EU and the maker is outside it, expect customs and import VAT, plus a handling fee from the courier in many cases. Some shops charge the VAT at checkout; with others, you pay on delivery. Also check:
- the delivery time, especially for made-to-order pieces;
- whether parcels are tracked;
- how the parcel is packed and labelled. Our discreet shopping guide covers this.
9. Returns, warranty and service
Opened intimate products usually cannot be returned for hygiene reasons, so the warranty and the maker's attitude to faults matter. Check:
- what happens if a toy arrives damaged or tears early;
- how long the warranty lasts, if there is one;
- how easy it is to contact the maker, and how quickly they answer.
10. Reputation
Look for real photos and experiences from other buyers, for example in community forums, rather than relying only on star ratings on the shop's own site. Be wary of reviews that all sound the same. And remember that people's preferences differ: a toy that is "too soft" for one person may be perfect for another.
Quick comparison checklist
| Check | What good looks like |
|---|---|
| Material | Platinum-cure silicone, clearly stated |
| Measurements | Length and width of each part listed |
| Firmness | Clear choices, with a description of each |
| Base | Flared, with the base width listed |
| Delivery | Realistic times, tracked shipping |
| Total cost | Shipping and import costs clear before you pay |
| Packaging | Discreet packaging explained |
| Service | Clear warranty and an easy way to get in touch |
How Velvet Hoard lists makers
We link to retailers and makers so that you can check every detail on their own websites. Some of our links are affiliate links, and we say so clearly next to every button. A commission never decides what we write in our guides. Read more in our Affiliate Disclosure, and explore Fantasy & Dragons to start comparing.
This guide is for general information about products for adults. It is not medical advice. Some links on Velvet Hoard are affiliate links: if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How affiliate links work